The printing industry is constantly evolving, with new techniques and methods emerging to bring artwork to life. At H F Screen Printing, we embrace this evolution wholeheartedly. We recognize that more consumers are becoming aware of the importance of sustainability and moving away from the fast fashion trend of excessive consumption.
It might seem paradoxical, considering we are a custom merchandise shop deeply involved in the production process. Yes, we produce a significant amount of merchandise—we embroider, create, print, and even wear it ourselves. However, what sets us apart is our commitment to sustainability throughout this production journey. We strive to support the planet by making environmentally conscious choices in the garment industry.
This brings us to the options available for bringing your designs to life while staying true to your values. We enjoy partnering with brands that care about sustainability as much as we do. Instead of pushing you to produce more merchandise mindlessly, we aim to help you make informed, eco-friendly decisions.
So, what’s the best option for your next batch of sustainable custom merchandise?
Let’s dive into the pros and cons of screen printing versus heat transfer to help you decide!
Screen Printing
First, let’s clarify that a lower upfront cost doesn’t always translate to a lower environmental impact. While Plastisol on Polyester is cheaper and easier, our focus here is on sustainable screen printing versus sustainable heat transfer.
Pros:
- Perfect for Large Orders: If you need to produce a large quantity of merchandise, screen printing is ideal. Our minimum order for screen printing is 50 pieces per design, making it cost-effective for bulk production. This method is especially efficient for larger orders, even though it requires a more intensive setup.
- Durability and Vibrancy: Screen prints are renowned for their durability and vibrant colors. Water-based inks, in particular, provide a high-quality result with a zero-feel finish, making the print feel like part of the fabric itself.
Cons:
- High Setup Costs and Longer Turnaround: The setup process for screen printing is more complex, leading to higher costs and longer turnaround times, especially for smaller orders.
- Less Suitable for Small Orders: For small batches, screen printing might not be the most sustainable choice due to the need for higher quantities.
Heat Transfer: The Versatile Alternative
Pros:
- Cost-effective Alternative to Embroidery: For items like hats, images with high print colors with low qty or logos requiring an ultrasmooth finish, heat transfer is a more economical option than embroidery, without sacrificing detail.
- Quick Turnaround and Lower Setup Costs: The process for heat transfer is streamlined, resulting in quicker turnaround times and lower setup costs compared to screen printing.
- Sustainability: Heat transfers support sustainable practices by reducing the need for overproduction. Our heat press designs use water-based inks and recycled transfer paper, enhancing their eco-friendliness.
- Low Minimums and Flexibility: While we handle large orders well, heat transfer is perfect for smaller quantities. With a minimum of just 20 pieces, it’s a flexible and cost-effective option for small-scale productions or samples.
Cons:
- Noticeable Texture: Heat transfers often add texture to the fabric, which can be less comfortable. This is particularly true for heat transfer vinyl, which we don’t recommend due to its lack of sustainability.
- Higher Costs for Large Orders: For large quantities, heat transfer can be more expensive and time-consuming than screen printing.
- Limited Durability: Although high quality, heat transfers may not last as long as screen prints, particularly with frequent washing.
Our Commitment to Quality and Sustainability
At H F Screen Printing, we use top-tier heat transfers from Supacolor. They produce the transfers, which we then apply to garments with our in-house heat press. This ensures each piece meets our high standards. Supacolor’s DTF heat transfers replicate the effect of traditional water-based screen printing, providing vibrant colors and intricate designs with the accessibility of digital direct-to-film printing.
Choosing the Right Method
When deciding between screen printing and heat transfer, consider factors like order size, turnaround time, cost, and alignment with your sustainability goals. At H F Screen Printing, we’re here to help you make the best choice for your brand, your audience, and the planet.
We’re passionate about every aspect of merch production—from design to the final printed product. Whether you choose the classic appeal of screen printing or the versatile benefits of heat transfers, we’re here to guide you through each step. Let’s make a sustainable impact together.
